Looking for Something?

PayPerPost to host blogging conference PostiCon…. Controversy follows

Author:

PayPerPost recently announced they will be holding PostiCon in Orlando and yesterday announced Robert Scoble (a member or our advisory council) will be giving the keynote.

Of course controversy insued. Robert disclosed that PayPerPost would be paying him a speaking fee (to his employer PodTech) on top of his travelling expenses. That got people up in arms.

Robert has now decided to decline their offer of a speaking fee and only accept reimbursement of his travelling expenses. /shrug I don’t see anything wrong with him getting paid or not getting paid particularly when he disclosed it on his blog.

More reaction at CrunchNotes, Ryan Stewart,

Chip Griffin

Honoraria are nothing new. Paying expenses for speakers is nothing new. The fact that Scoble disclosed it is admirable. Frankly, I’m not even sure it was necessary. Speaking at any organization’s invitation, with or without financial reimbursement, could conceivably bias a person anyway, so the mere act itself was probably sufficient.Â

But to me, the most troubling thing I take from this episode is the Blog Mob will even engage in self-righteous hysteria targeted at one of the more well-known and (generally) respected members of the blogosphere. We all need to remember that we can still agree to disagree. Despite what many bloggers seem to think, for most issues there is no right or wrong answer, simply two (or more) individual’s opinions.

So let’s all give Scoble a break.Â

Â

Joe Duck, webomatica, Dumpster Bust.

 Jim Kukral

News Flash: Scoble and the other big guns are not real bloggers. They are brands. Real bloggers are 63 million people who write a blog about office furniture or their day at work. It’s a huge difference.

I have to take issue with this. If you have a blog and your not a spammer you are a real blogger. No matter your topic; be it sports, politics, business, technology, milblogging, godblogging, celebrity gossip blogging, or talking about your office furniture.

If you are making a living blogging and have a hundred thousands of readers a day or you post about your cat and get 2 readers a month as long as you are using blog publishing software to post it then you are a real blogger.

I started writing this because imo the whole “who is a real blogger” controversy is silly. Jim is just the latest to claim to be the final arbiter of who a “real” blogger is and who isn’t. Possibly failing to recognize by his own standard he is not (a real blogger) therefore how can he be qualified to say who is?

Now that I have taken the time to write it, I realize I am just as silly for responding.

/shrugÂ

 Off to watch a SuperBowl that I could care less who wins. Hopefully it’s a good game.

Â

Rick is the CEO & Co-Founder of BlogWorld & New Media Expo. He lives in Canyon Lake with his wife and two dogs Abby and Thor.


Feedback

3
  • Jim Kukral

    I disagree. There is a distinction between a business that uses blog software, and “real” bloggers.

    At some point, when you become big enough, you stop being a “real” blogger, and become a business. Techcrunch, engadget, etc…

    Real bloggers don’t write blogs for the sole purpose of making money, nor did they start their blogs for that purpose. I see a clear difference.

  • Rick Calvert

    First of all thanks for stopping by and taking the time to Comment Jim. I know big bloggers like you are very busy.

    Wait by your definition you aren’t a “real blogger” =p. Sorry couldn’t resist.

    You sound like a music fan who likes to call his favorite band a sellout as soon as they land their first big record deal and then shuns them.

    Being successful doesn’t mean someone is fake. It usually means they are good at what they do. Sometimes it means they are lucky, or know how to play the system. (Just like music) or any other form of art or journalism. Some bands get big and keep it real to the end, some sell out. Some bloggers get big and keep it real, some sell out. Are you keeping it real Jim? I would say yes.

    Being real is what makes a blog real. Writing your own stuff instead of having a PR company do it is what makes a blog real. Allowing comments and not deleting those that disagree with you is what makes a blog real. Engaging with those who disagree with you is what makes a blog real.

    I am one of those bloggers who started purely for fun but I wouldn’t say my blog was any more real than say Jason Calacanis’ blog which was started purely for business reasons. He is about as opinionated a blogger as you will find and never backs down from an argument. He seems to start a lot of them 8).

    I’m sure I haven’t convinced you to change your opinion, but that’s all part of what makes blogging fun 8)

  • Jim Kukral

    “I’m sure I haven’t convinced you to change your opinion, but that’s all part of what makes blogging fun”

    Indeed!

Learn About NMX

NEW TWITTER HASHTAG: #NMX

Recent Comments

Categories

Archives